• From 1885 - 1901 the office of mayor was elected for 1 year
• Beginning in 1902 the office of mayor was elected for 2 years
• In 1967, by referendum, the position of mayor was made full-time

View List with Pictures Below

• 1885 - Colonel H. A. Frambach
• 1886 - Thomas Reese
• 1887-1888 - Peter Reuter
• 1889 -Michael Sullivan
• 1890-1891-1892 - Luther Lindauer
• 1893 - Peter Reuter
• 1894-1895 - Dr. H. B. Tanner
• 1896-1897 - Joseph McCarty
• 1898 - Charles E. Raught
• 1899 - F. M. Charlesworth
• 1900 - Julius Kuehn
• 1901 - C.D. Boyd
• [From this date on – the office of mayor was elected for 2 years]
• 1902 - H. J. Mulholland
• 1904-1906 - Charles E. Raught
• 1908 - Julius Kuehn [Died October 24, 1908]
• 1909 - Julius J. Martens [Filled the unexpired term of Julius Kuehn]
• 1910-1912-1914 - John Coppes
• 1916-1918-1920-1922 - Charles E. Raught
• 1926-1927 - Dr. W. C. Sullivan
• 1930-1932 - B.W. Fargo
• 1934-1936 - John H. Niesen
• 1937-1938 - L.F. Nelson
• 1940 - William F. Gantter [Died February 25, 1942 – His unexpired term was filled by L.F. Nelson]
• 1942-1944 - L.F. Nelson
• 1946-1948-1950-1952-1954-1956-1958-1960-1962-1964-1966 - Joseph F. Bayorgeon
• [Died August 10, 1966. Clayton Blumenich, as President of the council, was appointed temporary mayor for six days until Gilbert J. Anderson was elected by the City Council on 8/15/66 for the balance of the year]
• 1967-1968-1970 - Gilbert J. Anderson
• [In 1967, by referendum the position of mayor was made full-time]
• 1972-1974-1976-1978-1980 - Robert Lester LaPlante
• 1982-1984-1986-1988-1990-1992 - Ronald L. Van De Hey
• [Elected Outagamie County Executive in 1991. Howard McCabe, as president of the council, was appointed temporary mayor until the council elected Neal Steinberg in May of 1994. 
• 1994 - Neal Steinberg
• 1994-1998-2000-2002-2003 - John J. Lambie
• 2006 - Present - Eugene J. Rosin

Colonel H. A. Frambach   1885	Thomas Reese   1886	Peter Reuter   1887-1888	Michael Sullivan   1889
Luther Lindauer   1890-1891-1892	Peter Reuter   1893	Dr. H.B. Tanner   1894-1895	Joseph McCarty   1896 - 1897
Charles E. Raught   1898	F. M. Charlesworth   1899	Julius Keuhn   1900	C.D. Boyd   1901
H.J. Mulholland   1902	Charles E. Raught   1904 - 1908	Julius Keuhn   1908	Julius J. Martens   1909
John Coppes   1910- 1916	Charles E. Raught   1916-1926	Dr. William Sullivan   1926-1928	B.W. Fargo   1930-1934
John H. Niesen   1934-1936	L.F. Nelson   1937-1938-1939	William F. Ganttner   1940 - 1942	L.F. Nelson   1942-1944
Joseph F. Bayorgeon   1946 - 1966	Clayton Blumerich Aug. 10th 1966 - Aug. 16th, 1966	Gilbert J. Anderson 1967 - 1970	Robert L. LaPlante   1972 - 1982
Ronald L. Van De Hey   1982 - 1992	Howard McCabe   April 16th, 1991 - May 10th, 1991	Neal Steinberg   1992 - 1994	John J. Lambie 1994 - 2006
Eugene J. Rosin 2006 - Present	Anthony Penterman 2018 - Present